… When Judicial Pronouncements Meet The Fragile Temperament Of Electoral Democracy
By Charles Edet Esq, FCR
The ballot box does not merely sustain democracy; it equally depends on the impartiality, credibility and timeliness of judicial interventions. The recent Federal High Court judgment of November 5, 2026, delivered by Justice Peter Lifu, nullifying the David Mark-led leadership of the African Democratic Congress (ADC) and invalidating the presidential nomination of former Vice President Atiku Abubakar, has introduced another formidable controversy into Nigeria’s already turbulent political atmosphere.
The contention is not whether the judiciary possesses constitutional authority to adjudicate internal political disputes. It unquestionably does. The more consequential question is whether the timing and eventual implications of such judicial pronouncements adequately accommodate the larger interests of democratic stability, political participation and national cohesion.
When politically consequential litigation remains unresolved until electoral preparations are considerably advanced, the resulting uncertainty becomes fertile ground for political desperation, suspicion, inflammatory rhetoric and unnecessary national tension.
Under Sections 6 and 36 of the 1999 Constitution, judicial authority and fair hearing are fundamental constitutional safeguards, while Section 40 protects freedom of association. These principles must operate together. Political parties must obey their constitutions and electoral laws, but judicial intervention must equally command confidence through consistency, procedural fairness and respect for established judicial precedents.
There is an historical political statement worth recalling. On December 15, 2010, during the National Stakeholders’ Conference at the ThisDay Dome, Abuja,
Atiku Abubakar, then a PDP presidential aspirant challenging the party’s zoning arrangement ahead of the 2011 presidential election, quoted the expression: “Those who make peaceful change impossible, make violent change inevitable.” He subsequently clarified that violence was not what he wanted for Nigeria. Importantly, the separate threat that Nigeria would be made ungovernable for President Goodluck Jonathan was attributed to a politician and former Kaduna governor, Lawal Kaita, not Atiku. Pertinently, political loyalists and opposition-inclined journalists and party supporters should not twist history purposefully for their interest. Historical accuracy must prevail over political convenience.
The law of retribution reminds political actors that what one sows, one may eventually reap. Nevertheless, democratic justice must never become an instrument of political vengeance. Today’s judicial decisions may establish precedents that tomorrow’s political opponents will invoke against their beneficiaries.
The critical question is whether Nigeria needs judicial decisions that consolidate peaceful coexistence or decisions whose timing, rightly or wrongly, creates combustible political apprehension. Does democracy benefit when consequential electoral disputes reach decisive judicial stages so close to campaigns and elections? The judiciary must appreciate that justice delayed can undermine confidence, even where the eventual decision is legally sustainable.
Atiku’s political relevance and President Tinubu’s electoral prospects should be determined through democratic competition, not conjecture. No political contestant should be insulated from legitimate scrutiny, nor should any opposition party be deprived of its lawful opportunity to participate.
Nevertheless, the ADC must demonstrate institutional maturity by respecting the judgment while pursuing its constitutional right of appeal. Its supporters must reject violence, intimidation and unlawful demonstrations.
Nigeria’s democracy must survive its present challenges. The judiciary must protect justice, politicians must respect the law, and the government must preserve an environment in which opposition thrives. The survival of democracy must be greater than the ambition of any politician or the fortunes of any political party.